September is an exciting time of year. It hallmarks the unofficial beginning of fall and all things pumpkin flavored and a very exciting holiday — National Pepperoni Pizza Day. Falling on September 20th, celebrating this holiday is easy, especially here in the Mile Square, as the city is filled with pizza shops.
The pepperoni was first introduced as a pizza topping in the early 1900s in New York City and more than a century later, we are still enjoying this Lower Manhattan creation. With countless options for pizza toppings, pepperoni pizza remains the most popular pizza today. You might have a go-to spot but check out this roundup and maybe try someplace new this National Pepperoni Pizza Day.
Pizzeria Hoboken {732 Jefferson Street}
{Photo credit: @pizzeriahoboken}
A casual Italian restaurant serving delicious freshly-made pizza and traditional Italian meals. The pizza dough at this locale is made fresh daily and all the sauces are homemade — #score.
Price: 16” Pepperoni Pie: $20.50
Old Lorenzo’s Pizza {301 Jackson Street}
Boasting an old family recipe for homemade sauce, Old Lorenzo’s Pizza also touts its crust as something that sets the pizza here apart from the rest.
Price: 16” Pepperoni Pie: $19.50
Pizza Republic {406 Washington Street}
{Photo credit: @pizzarepublicnj}
Opened in 2009, with the tagline “Cheese, Love, Rock N’ Roll,” this local shop goes beyond pizza. Also known as the Mac Daddy of Hoboken, Pizza Republic offers over 17 different types of mac and cheese dishes {for a seriously indulgent outing at this local spot}.
Price: 18” Pepperoni Pie: $18.00
Urban Coalhouse Pizza + Bar {116 14th Street}
{Photo credit: @urbancoalhouse}
Dive into generation’s old dishes crafted from authentic recipes baked in an800° degree coal-fired oven. Urban Coalhouse uses the freshest, highest-quality ingredients in its signature menu so you can enjoy the food you have and the company you’re with. Pro-tip, order the Don Gregorio pie.
Price: 16” Pepperoni Pie: $21.00
Read More: The Best Hoboken Pizza Spots {According to Your Cravings}
Torna’s Pizzeria {254 9th Street}
{Photo credit: @tornaspizzahoboken}
Family-owned since 1968, Torna’s is a no-frills restaurant offering an old school slice of pizza. Reviews from locals suggest this is a go-to spot to satisfy those late-night pizza cravings. Pro-trip, they have one of the best Sicilian pies in town.
Price: 18” Pepperoni Pie: $24.00
Napoli’s Pizza {1118 Washington Street}
{Photo credit: @napolishoboken}
With its true Neapolitan-style pizza, fresh pasta, paninis, and wraps, there’s something for everyone at Napoli’s. Owner Frank Volpe worked in his family’s pizzeria, Lombardi’s for 12 years before branching out on his own.
Price: 18” Pepperoni Pie: $18.85
The Brick {1122 Washington Street}
{Photo credit: @the_brick_hoboken}
Known for its modern interpretation of classic dishes, The Brick is a cornerstone of the Hoboken community. Enjoy pizza, pasta, and sandwiches from this high-quality shop.
Price: 18” Pepperoni Pie: $19.95
See More: Where to Find Vegan Pizza in Hoboken, Jersey City, + Beyond
Rosario’s at Willow {1132 Willow Avenue}
A staple since 1996, Rosario’s used local ingredients to get creative with recipes. Check out our 2019 article for more of this spot’s history!
16” Pepperoni Pie”: $19.45
Benny Tudino’s {622 Washington Street}
{Photo credit: @bennytudinos}
Home of the biggest slice in Hoboken, your stomach had better be as big as your eyes when ordering at Benny Tudino’s. Go for the authentic experience and order the 32” House Pie with a {socially distanced} group or grab a slice on your own for a quick bite. Either way, Benny Tudino’s has been around for 40 years for a huge, cheese-covered reason.
Price: 18” Pepperoni Pie: $20.00
The great debate of what makes the perfect pizza is never-ending. Tell us in the comments which Hoboken restaurant makes your favorite slice!
