The Hoboken Girl Team 
Thanksgiving is a few weeks away — and we all know this holiday requires some serious planning. Whether hosting the holidays this year or just looking for a top-notch dessert to bring as a guest, we’ve rounded up some local bakeries, restaurants, and cafes in Hoboken, Jersey City, and Bayonne that are selling pies for Thanksgiving. We’re talking apple, pumpkin, pecan, and more. Read on for a guide to Thanksgiving pies in the Hudson County area.
Please note: This is a growing list. To request an addition, please send us a note at [email protected].
Hoboken
Carlo’s Bakery | 95 Washington Street
It’s all about Carlo’s this holiday season with plenty of baked goods to share, including the classics like apple pie, pumpkin pie, and pecan pie. You can pick up a pie in the store or via the website.
Read More: Holiday Pop-Up Markets + Bars in New Jersey for the 2024 Season
Choc-O-Pain French Bakery and Café | Multiple Locations
View this post on Instagram
Award-winning Choc O Pain Bakery is ready for Thanksgiving. The seasonal pie flavors include pumpkin tart, pecan tart, caramel apple tarte, spiced almond creme cranberry tart, and more will be available to place for a future hour (must be at least 48 hours in advance). Click here to place a future order.
Jersey City
Busy Bee Organics | 451 Palisade Avenue
Busy Bee Organics will have an entire Thanksgiving catering menu that’s all allergy- and dietary-restriction-friendly. Gluten-free, soy-free, nut-free, and vegan options will all be an offer here; all guests will be able to enjoy the classic seasonal tastes like apple crumble. In years past, customers enjoyed apple crumble pie, pumpkin loaf, pumpkin cheesecake, maple cinnamon whipped cream, and more. Busy Bee Organics will announce its Thanksgiving catering menu in the next few weeks, so check out the website here.
Café Madelaine | 34 Coles Street
View this post on Instagram
Don’t let the laid-back vibes of this chic café deceive you: the pastries here are serious business, and that includes pies. For Thanksgiving, patrons can enjoy all of the traditional flavors of the season with a distinctly European slant. Pecan pies, apple crumbles, and pumpkin individual tarts are available — and that’s just a few. Call or email to place an order. The Café offers local delivery as well.
Jam Cakery Events | 326 5th Street
View this post on Instagram
Downtown Jersey City’s Jam Cakery Events is our go-to for keeping even the most restrictive dietary needs in mind, and making everything taste delicious. From sugar-free, gluten-free, vegan, to raw, there is an option for everyone. The omnivorous guests won’t even notice the difference. When it comes to pies, you can find pumpkin marshmallow pie, smores cream pie, apple peach crumble pie, and much more. The company is accepting orders from now until November 22nd.
Sugartown Bakery Cafe | 437 Jersey Avenue
This bakery and cafe will provide all kinds of Thanksgiving delicacies. Customers can look forward to eight-inch or ten-inch apple, sweet potato, pecan, pumpkin, and blueberry pies. To place an order, patrons must call the bakery at (201) 333 – 6600.
Scram | 61 Erie Street
This Hamilton Park coffee and pastry shop has a cult following for its breakfast sandwiches and a rotating menu of pastries. While there are no details yet about the bakery’s Thanksgiving selections in 2025, the Scram Fam has previously offered pies and other treats via preorder for pickup. Last year’s choices included pumpkin pie, and honey pecan, among others.
Bayonne
Judicke’s Bakery | 763 Broadway Avenue
This Bayonne bakery never disappoints, offering just about any dessert one could want including apple crumb and apple + pumpkin pies, all made fresh. The bakery also sells mini pumpkin and pecan pies for individual festive desserts. And don’t forget to get a doughnut or a dozen on the way out. Throughout November, these baked-goods will be available in store but customers also have the option of pre-ordering them for the holiday.
See More: Where to Order Thanksgiving Pies in Montclair + Beyond
Paulanto Bakery | 387 Broadway Avenue
Aside from custom-made cakes, Paulanto will have Thanksgiving pies available towards the end of November. Flavors include pumpkin, coconut custard, pecan, apple, apple crumble, cherry, and blueberries. There will be 7-inch and 10-inch pie options to choose from.
Bonus
Paris Baguette | 1000 Maxwell Lane, Hoboken
View this post on Instagram
This French bakery will not serve Thanksgiving pies this holiday season but Thanksgiving cakes. At Paris Baguette, the holiday menu includes a cookie butter New York-style cheesecake, complete with a cream and cookie topping. Previous years have included a maple-pecan cake and a salted caramel and chocolate mousse cake. To see the full Thanksgiving cake menu, see here.
