Your Guide to Thanksgiving Pies in Hoboken, Jersey City, + Bayonne

Written by:

Whether hosting the holidays this year or just looking for a top-notch dessert to bring as a guest, we’ve got the scoop on places in Hoboken, Jersey City, and beyond to get delightful fresh-baked pies this Thanksgiving. 

Hoboken

Carlo’s Bakery | 95 Washington Street

carlos bakery pie

(Photo credit: @carlosbakery)

It’s all about Carlo’s this holiday season with plenty of baked goods to share, including the classics like apple crumb, pumpkin pie, blueberry, coconut cheese, chocolate pecan pie, and more including a wide variety of cheesecakes to choose from.

Choc-O-Pain French Bakery and Café | 157 1st Street, 1500 Hudson Street, Hoboken + 530 Jersey Avenue, 330-332 Palisade Avenue, Jersey City

Award-winning Choc•O•Pain Bakery is ready for Thanksgiving pre-orders. The seasonal pie flavors include pumpkin tart, pecan tart, pear almond cream tart, vegan chocolate ganache almonds tart, apricot pistachio tart, and apple tarte tatin will be available every weekend. The bakery also has holiday-designed bread, perfect for those that are hosting guests. Click here to order delivery.

Dolce & Salato | 1101 Grand Street

dolce and salato

(Photo credit: @dolceandsalato_hoboken)

This bakery features tons of Italian baked goodies including fresh gelato and pies like apricot, Nutella apple, and more, all of which can be pre-ordered and picked up.

Malibu Diner | 257 14th Street

malibu diner

(Photo credit: @malibudiner)

Believe it or not, this diner has a pretty stellar selection of pies, including whipped cream pies (available in chocolate, banana, and lemon meringue), assorted fruit pies, and of course, a variety of cakes – just make sure you call in advance to order.

Read More: Where to Get Pumpkin Beers in Hoboken + Jersey City

Old German Bakery | 322 Washington Street

Old German Bakery

(Photo credit: @oldgermanbakery)

This authentic German bakery features German apple pie (think regular apple pie but with more apples layered on top of each other – yum), peach yogurt pie, cheese crumb, plum crumb, apple crumb, and more.

Sirenetta | 1039 Washington Street

Sirenetta and Sorellina will be hosting a pop-up holiday market, with delicious pies available, amongst other goodies. The pie flavors include apple, pumpkin, and chocolate pecan. Even better? A mini pie trio is also available for those who need a bite of all the flavors. Pre-order only, for pickup on Tuesday, November 23rd after 2PM.

Sweet | 343 Garden Street

This adorable cup-cakery with tons of cakes and cupcakes in fun flavors will be featuring pies this Turkey Day including pumpkin, key lime, pecan, and apple crumble.  Place orders before November 19th to ensure availability. 

The Hive | 1000 Park Avenue

The Hive has added pies to the menu for the season! They are currently offering gluten-free and vegan pies from Om Sweet Home; a perfect addition to the table this Thanksgiving.

Jersey City

Busy Bee Organics | 451 Palisade Avenue and 175 2nd Street

Busy Bee Organics has an entire suite of pies and other sweet treats, and they are all allergy- and dietary-restriction friendly. Gluten-free, soy-free, nut-free, and vegan options are all on offer here: all guests will be able to enjoy the classic seasonal tastes like pumpkin, maple, eggnog, and apple. Orders should be placed by November 21st to ensure availability.

Café Madelaine | 34 Coles Street 

Don’t let the laid-back vibes of this chic café deceive: the pastries here are serious business, and that includes pies. For Thanksgiving, patrons can enjoy all of the traditional flavors of the season with a distinctly European slant. The pumpkin tart, pictured above, is a work of art, with seasoned pumpkin seeds for garnish. Pecan tarts, apple crumbles, and a pear bourdaloue tart, which is an almond tart with poached pears, are also available. Call or email to place an order. The Café offers local delivery as well.

Cocoa Bakery | 275 Grand Street and 475 Central Avenue

This Jersey City bakery will not only have all of the classic pie options, but it will also offer some gluten-free choices. Diners can choose from apple pie, apple oat crumb pie, pecan honey caramel pie, sweet potato with toasted meringue pie, pumpkin pie, and gluten-free pumpkin pie. Pre-orders are recommended and can be placed by calling the bakery at 201-830-3430.

Jam Cakery Events | 326 5th Street

Downtown Jersey City’s Jam Cakery Events is our-go to for keeping even the most restrictive dietary needs in mind, and making everything taste delicious. From sugar-free, gluten-free, vegan, to raw, there is an option for everyone. The omnivorous guests won’t even notice the difference. Orders can be placed by phone or email, and can be delivered or picked up. Everyone’s favorite flavors are included, like s’mores, pumpkin, apple, and sticky toffee.

 

See More: The Best New Jersey Spots for Festive Fall Foliage


Morton Williams | 105 River Drive

The only thing better than the amazing variety of pies at Morton Williams is that they can be delivered. Yes, that’s right, for locations within the store’s delivery zone or within Instacart’s borders, diners can have their choice of pie without having to leave the house. Menu options include sweet potato, apple crumb, pumpkin, and pecan pies.

Monteleone’s Bakery | 741 Newark Avenue

Monteleone’s Bakery

Offering festive and well-priced seasonal cakes as well as cookies and pastries, check out this neighborhood bakery for classic staples like pumpkin and apple pie this holiday. Preorders can be placed by phone or in person, and don’t forget, this Journal Square landmark is a cash-only operation.

Salt + Seed | 210 Hudson Street

This vegan spot in the District Kitchen Food Hall in Harborside started off as a stand at the Uptown Hoboken Farmer’s Market in the spring of 2017. Now, Salt + Seed serves its elevated vegan food to patrons Mondays through Thursdays, and the house-made, vegan menu is available for catering as well. For the holidays, everyone’s seasonal favorite flavors are on offer, including an apple crumble and a pumpkin mousse. Preorders are required and can be placed via the restaurant’s website.

Scram | 61 Erie Street

This Hamilton Park coffee and pastry shop has a cult following for its breakfast sandwiches and a rotating menu of pastries. For Thanksgiving, the Scram Fam will offer pies and other treats via preorder. Choices include Apple Crumb, French Silk, and Honey Pecan, among others. Order online and pick up at the store on either Tuesday, November 23rd or Wednesday, November 24th to have everything ready for the big day.

Sugartown Bakery Café | 437 Jersey Avenue

Besides making ah-mazing custom cakes and cupcakes, Sugartown also offers a plethora of pies that customers can buy wholesale, including strawberry, raspberry, blueberry, lemon meringue, coconut, sweet potato, apple, pumpkin, pecan, and more.

The Cookie Cake Company | 136 Monticello Avenue

This woman-owned company is known for its creative and ‘insane’ cookie cakes nationwide and with those fun cakes, they feature a few holiday ones as well. They are currently offering a pumpkin and chocolate chip Thanksgiving cookie until November 21st.

Bayonne

Judicke’s Bakery | 763 Broadway Avenue

judickes bakery pies bayonne

This Bayonne bakery never disappoints, offering just about any dessert one could want including cheesecake and apple + pumpkin pies, all made fresh. And don’t forget to get a doughnut or a dozen on the way out.

Paulanto Bakery | 387 Broadway Avenue

Aside from custom-made cakes, check out the array of fruit tarts, cheesecake (especially the raspberry — yum), and pies at Paulanto including banana cream pie, apple, and pumpkin.

email buttons


Written by: