Where to Find Thanksgiving Pies in Hoboken, Jersey City, + Bayonne

Written by:

Thanksgiving is this week — so it’s time to loosen those belts and get ready for all of the yummy dishes and treats this holiday has to offer. Whether you are hosting the holidays this year or just looking for a top-notch dessert to bring as a guest {or if you aren’t too skilled in the kitchen and don’t want to risk a turkey day tragedy} we’ve got the scoop on places in Hoboken, Jersey City and beyond to get delightful fresh-baked pies this Thanksgiving


carlos bakery pies hoboken

Photo: @carlosbakery on Instagram

Carlo’s Bakery {95 Washington Street}

It’s all about Carlo’s this holiday season with plenty of baked goods to spare, including the classics like apple crumb, pumpkin pie, blueberry, coconut cheese, chocolate pecan pie, and more including a wide variety of cheesecakes to choose from.

Old German Bakery {322 Washington Street}

This authentic German bakery features German apple pie {think regular apple pie but with more apples layered on top of each other – yum}, peach yogurt pie, cheese crumb, plumb crumb, apple crumb and more.

Malibu Diner {257 14th Street}

Believe it or not, this diner has a pretty stellar selection of pies, including whipped cream pies {available in chocolate, banana and lemon meringue}, assorted fruit pies, and of course, a variety of cakes – just make sure you call in advance to order.

Dolce & Salato {1101 Grand Street}

This recently opened bakery features tons of Italian baked goodies including fresh gelato and pies like apricot, Nutella {whaaat}, apple, and more, all of which can be pre-ordered and picked up.

The Brass Rail {135 Washington Street}

Also offering catering this Thanksgiving season that includes turkey and all the fixings, The Brass Rail will have pumpkin cheesecake, apple pie and pecan pie on their catering and pick-up menu for the holiday.

Baking Mama {88 Hudson Street}

Featuring beautiful cupcakes, tasty cookies {gluten free and vegan options available} and colorful desserts, Baking Mama will offer specialty pies and Thanksgiving macaroons this holiday for purchase.

Sweet {343 Garden Street}

This adorable cup-cakery with tons of cakes and cupcakes in fun flavors will be featuring pies this turkey day including pumpkin, key lime, pecan, chocolate pecan, and caramel apple {our money is on this one}.

READ: Hoboken and Jersey City Restaurants Open on Thanksgiving {2018}

Jersey City

cocoa bakery jersey city pie

Dulce De Leche Bakery {376 Central Avenue}

Offering custom cakes, fresh pastries, empanadas and more, Dulce De Leche will also be serving pumpkin pies available for purchase for the holidays.

Choc O Pain {530 Jersey Ave & 330 Palisade Avenue}

With two locations in Jersey City and two in Hoboken, Choc O Pain is a great place to get your baked goodies including plum, apple, and raspberry tarts, as well as seasonal pies.

Cocoa Bakery {275 Grand Street}

This bakery has all pies both sweet and savory this holiday season, including a sweet potato meringue pie, apple crumb pie, pecan pie, and pumpkin pie. The shop will also be offering two gluten-free options — apple crumb {individual servings only} and pumpkin pie.

Cheesecake Factory {Newport Centre Mall, 30 Mall Drive West}

Always a prime spot for a rich treat, the Cheesecake Factory offers both 10-inch whole cheesecakes and 6 & 7-inch cheesecakes in all of the luscious varieties available in-store, including Oreo Dream Extreme Cheesecake, White Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Cheesecake, Pumpkin Pecan Cheesecake, Carrot Cake Cheesecake and many, many more.

Enna Bakery {61 Erie Street}

Recently opened in Jersey City, Enna Bakery sells fresh-baked breads and sandwiches in a cozy setting. Enna will have apple, blueberry, pumpkin and pecan pie available for purchase this holiday season. 

Sugartown Bakery Café {437 Jersey Avenue}

Besides making ah-mazing custom cakes and cupcakes, Sugartown also offers a plethora of pies that customers can buy wholesale, including strawberry, raspberry, blueberry, lemon meringue, coconut, sweet potato, apple, pumpkin, pecan and more.

Monteleone’s Bakery {741 Newark Avenue}

Offering festive and well-priced seasonal cakes as well as cookies and pastries, check out this neighborhood bakery for the classic staples like pumpkin and apple pie this holiday.

See More: Navigate the Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade {Like a Pro}


judickes bakery pies bayonne

Photo: @judickesbakery on Instagram

Judicke’s Bakery {763 Broadway}

This Bayonne bakery never disappoints, offering just about any dessert one could want including cheesecake and apple + pumpkin pies, all made fresh. And don’t forget to get a doughnut {or a dozen} on your way out.

Paulanto Bakery {387 Broadway}

Aside from custom-made cakes, check out the array of fruit tarts, cheesecake {especially the raspberry — yum} and pies at Paulanto including banana cream pie, apple, and pumpkin.

Where will you be picking up a pie this holiday? Share with us in the comments below!

Have you joined our Facebook group yet? Request here to gain access to even more local tips, and connect with fellow Hudson County residents.

Join Our Mailing List

Deals, News, + Everything Local

Written by:

Lauren originally hails from Nutley, NJ but is happy and proud to have called Bayonne her hometown for the past 5 years, where she can always find a beautiful park to walk or run in and a great place to eat. Lauren has a deep appreciation for a good bar, a great glass of red wine, and good food, and often frequents Jersey City for dining, where she worked for 4 years. Now working in NYC, Lauren still gets her Jersey City fix on the weekends or after work, and then goes back to her apartment where she lives with her husband, a Bayonne native, and her awesome kitty, Lola. You can also find her at yoga class in Jersey City or Hoboken, writing, or reading {and continually running out of space for all of her books} in her spare time.