5 Spots to Eat Pie in Hoboken and Jersey City

Written by:

Everyone deserves some dessert every now and again, so go ahead, indulge. There are tons of places to find dessert in Hoboken, yet the ones below serve pie, and may we add they serve it pretty deliciously, too. Be sure to stop in for a bite or take your slice to go and enjoy the comfort of your home. Keep reading to discover five spots to eat pie in  Hoboken+  Jersey City.

Pie 66 {150 Bay Street, Jersey City + 153 1st Street, Hoboken}

pie 66 popup

{Photo courtesy of Bucket + Bay}

As the newest popup from Bucket + Bay, Pie 66 will be offering a selection of homestyle pies. Plus, the pies will be made with a variety of healthy ingredients. Oh, and there will also be an option to pair your pie with a scoop of gelato — the ultimate combo.

Malibu Diner {257 14th Street, Hoboken}

 The Malibu Diner is a 24-hour diner located at 14th and Park. The spot has been open since the ’40s — but recreated as a more modern spot —and it can host small groups or large groups {there’s a ton of space!}. Plus, there’s free {yes, free} parking.

Brownstone Diner & Pancake Factory {Multiple Locations}

The Brownstone Diner & Pancake Factory has been providing delicious pancakes and desserts for the Jersey City/Hoboken area for over 47 years {and they have locations in Edgewater and Englewood Cliffs, too}. Their JC spot is located at 437 Jersey Avenue, and the diner has a variety of mouth-watering pies that are sure to complete your celebrations. The delectable selection includes fruit pies {blueberry, apple or coconut custard}, banana cream, chocolate cream, lemon meringue, and key lime pie. Decisions, decisions!

Who’s Gluten Free {80 Mallory Avenue, Jersey City}


Who’s Gluten Free is a bakery dedicated to baking and creating nutritious, gluten-free treats for the public. The health-focused company works to create delicious new recipes for people to try — and whether you are gluten-free or just looking for a nutritious treat, their creations are delish.

Otto Strada {743 Park Avenue, Jersey City}

nutella pie blue eyes hoboken

If a “pizza” pie counts, then you’re in luck. One of our fave Nutella “pies” are from Otto Strada — they have one of the most delicious Nutella pizza pies in the biz.

So there you have it — 7 spots to get your pie day on. What’s your favorite? Would love to hear!

Written by:

Jen is a thirty-something mama with three kids under five in Hoboken. Yes, it can be done! She is also the co-founder and CEO of Local Barre, a boutique core fitness with three locations in Hoboken. Life with kids (and a business!) in Hoboken can be chaotic and Jen is ready to share her tips for balancing it all as a "veteran" Mama in this city.