With Valentine’s Day less than a week away, love is in the air and many locals are planning how to spend the day. From making a reservation at a local restaurant or planning a unique date night, there are many different ways to celebrate. While heart-shaped sweet treats abound this time of year, we want to shout out one of our favorite savory treats that suits any occasion: pizza. For Valentine’s Day, many restaurants in Hoboken + Jersey City have heart-shaped pizzas that are Instagram-worthy and make a fun food-related way to celebrate Valentine’s Day. Read on for spots to get heart-shaped pizza in Hoboken + Jersey City.
Hoboken
Benny Tudino’s | 622 Washington Street
Photo Credit: @bennytudinos
Known as the “Home of the Largest Slice,” Benny Tudino’s is bringing its take on a heart-shaped pizza this Valentine’s Day. Customers can choose any toppings of their choosing like mushrooms, onions, sausage, pepperoni, black olives, garlic, spinach, buffalo chicken, or tomato.
Blue Eyes Restaurant | 525 Sinatra Drive
Photo Credit: @blueeyeshoboken
Located on Hoboken’s waterfront, Blue Eyes will turn its classic pizzas into heart-shaped ones. Rather than keeping its dough the regular crispy, golden color, Blue Eyes is taking it to the next level. The pizza’s dough will come in red to represent the holiday’s symbolic color. Patrons can enjoy the pizza either by dining in or ordering for takeout.
Read More: Where to Get Pizza Dough in Hoboken + Jersey City
H+S Giovanni’s Restaurant + Pizzeria | 603 Washington Street
View this post on Instagram
H+S Giovanni’s will make custom heart-shaped pizzas starting this week. The pizzas are lined with garlic knots and pepperoni. Orders must be placed in advance and customers can call (201) 714-4232 for more details.
Imposto’s Pizza | 102 Washington Street
Photo Credit: @impostoshoboken
Imposto’s in Hoboken will have special, limited-edition pizzas this Valentine’s Day. There will be choices such as Pizza My Heart ($21), Vodka ($26), Heart A Rita ($26), and Buffalove ($29) — that of course come in a heart shape. It will be available from Monday, February 12th to Wednesday, February 14th.
Leo’s Grandevous | 200 Grand Street
Photo Credit: @leosgrandevous
Leo’s Grandevous has been serving its Hoboken neighbors since 1939. And of course, Valentine’s Day is no exception. Its original heart-shaped pizza will be served — for dine-in service only.
Quality Pizza Co. | 304 Washington Street
Photo Credit: @qualitypizzaco
Quality Pizza’s menu is packed with choices of round pies, square pies, personal pies, and a gluten-free crust. Featured toppings include pepperoni, mushroom, buffalo chicken, and plain, as well as a sausage jalapeno, vodka, and vegetable, among other options. These flavors can be enjoyed in Quality Pizza Co.’s version of a heart-shaped pizza.
San Giuseppe | 1320 Adams Street
Photo Credit: @sg_hoboken
San Giuseppe is known for its coal-fired pizzas, homemade pasta, entrees like meatball sliders to rice balls, and desserts like cannoli to rainbow cake. The Italian restaurant will have a heart-shaped pizza for customers on Valentine’s Day. This cheesy dish will be available as a dine-in and take-out option.
The Brick | 1122 Washington Street
Photo Credit: @the_brick_hoboken
This Hoboken restaurant will have two different heart-shaped pizza options. It will have a savory option that will be available in a personal and medium size. Gluten-free and vegan options are available upon request. The second heart-shaped pizza choice is a “Sweetheart Pie” — made with Nutella, fresh strawberries, and bananas.
The Madison Bar + Grill | 1316 Washington Street
Photo Credit: @_madisonbarandgrill
This local spot has been a long-standing Hoboken staple since the ’90s. With its specialty cocktails and burgers, patrons shouldn’t skip over its pizza. This Valentine’s Day, its heart-shaped pizza will be made with Italian flour, fresh tomatoes, and mozzarella. For a sweet option, patrons can try out its dessert pizza. It will be made with cinnamon, nutmeg, sugar, and a Nutella mascarpone blend. For toppings, fruit, fresh mint, and a raspberry sauce are drizzled to tie in the combination of flavors.
Jersey City
Pompei Pizza | 722 West Side Avenue
Photo Credit: @pompeipizzajc
This Valentine’s Day. Pompeii Pizza will have two unique takes on its pizzas. Customers can order one option which is a plain heart pizza and have the chance to add toppings of their choice. Another option is the pepperoni heart pie which can be ordered in a 16-inch ($20) or 18-inch size ($25). Toppings can also be added when ordering. These pizzas will be available on Friday, Saturday, Sunday, Tuesday, and Wednesday.
Rizzo Bakery | 208 Central Avenue
Photo Credit: @rizzosbakery
This family-run business has been around since 1983 and serves fresh baked goods like bread, cookies, and pizza. For Valentine’s Day, any large pie can be made into a heart-shaped pizza.
Rustique Pizza | 611 Jersey Avenue
Photo Credit: @rustiquepizza
Rustique Pizza will have three different choices of heart-shaped pizzas. There will be a cheese and pepperoni option. Both flavors can also be combined into a half-and-half option.
Space Pizza | 514 Ocean Avenue + 140 Ocean Avenue
With two locations in Jersey City, Space Pizza brings a variety of pizza choices and wing options to choose from. For Valentine’s Day, customers have the chance to customize their heart-shaped pizza. From toppings like mushrooms to pepperoni, Space Pizza has a total of 18 choices to choose from to satisfy any kind of taste buds.
See More: Unique Pizza You *MUST * Order in North Jersey
Tony Boloney’s | 263 1st Street, Hoboken + 363 Grove Street, Jersey City
Photo Credit: @tonyboloneys
With four locations in New Jersey, Tony Boloney’s will have two choices of heart-shaped pizzas. There will be a garlic knot pizza and a pink heart glitter pizza that will make you ditch the average box of chocolate this Valentine’s Day. Pink Flaming Hot Cheeto mozzarella sticks will also be available to pair with the pizza of the customer’s choosing.
